Brand New Five Below / PetSmart Redevelopment For Sale
$7,870,000
4121 Calumet Avenue, Manitowoc, WI 54220
6.25
Cap Rate
491,742
NOI
Details:
Highlights:
- ESTABLISHED CALUMET AVENUE LOCATION: The Property is strategically positioned along the Highway 42 / Calumet Avenue corridor, Manitowoc’s dominant retail destination, and directly adjacent to a high-performing Walmart Supercenter. The corridor’s concentration of national retailers draws shoppers from a broad regional trade area extending beyond Manitowoc, including communities from Sheboygan to Denmark and west toward Chilton. This established regional draw, combined with Walmart’s traffic and surrounding national retailers, provides PetSmart and Five Below access to a deep customer base with established shopping patterns along the corridor.
- NEW 10-YEAR NATIONAL RETAIL LEASES: The Property will be fully leased to PetSmart and Five Below under new 10-year leases. PetSmart has four five-year extension options, while Five Below has three five-year extension options, providing meaningful potential tenancy beyond the initial terms.
- CONTRACTUAL RENT GROWTH: Both leases provide built-in rent growth during the initial term. PetSmart and Five Below feature 10% rent increase beginning in Lease Year 6. Additional rental increases are incorporated throughout each tenant’s renewal option periods, providing investors with embedded NOI growth.
- COMPLEMENTARY TENANT MIX: PetSmart combines recurring pet-product demand with service-oriented uses such as grooming, training and related pet care. Five Below adds a value-focused, high-traffic retail concept with a broad merchandise assortment. Together, the tenants create a diversified two-tenant income stream.
- NEW 20-YEAR ROOF WARRANTY: The Property recently received a new roof backed by a 20-year warranty, providing investors with limited near-term capital expenditure requirements and enhancing the long-term durability of the asset. The recent roof replacement is part of the comprehensive redevelopment of the Property and further supports the stability of the investment
Description:
Mid-America Real Estate – Wisconsin, LLC has been exclusively retained by ownership to offer the fee simple interest in PetSmart / Five Below, a newly redeveloped two-tenant national retail asset located at 4121 Calumet Avenue in Manitowoc, Wisconsin. The former OfficeMax building underwent a comprehensive renovation in 2026 to accommodate PetSmart and Five Below for a 2027 opening. The Property contains approximately 23,487 square feet and is 100% leased to two nationally recognized retailers.
The offering provides investors with the opportunity to acquire a newly repositioned retail property supported by fresh 10-year leases, contractual rent growth, multiple renewal options, and a highly functional location within Manitowoc’s primary Calumet Avenue retail corridor. The Property is shadow anchored by a high-performing Walmart Supercenter that ranks 16th out of 86 Walmart locations in Wisconsin and generates approximately 2.6 million annual visits according to Placer.ai.
PetSmart / Five Below is a newly renovated two-tenant retail property located at 4121 Calumet Avenue in Manitowoc, Wisconsin. The Property consists of approximately 23,487 square feet and is 100% leased to PetSmart and Five Below, two nationally recognized retailers with new long-term lease commitments. The redevelopment transformed a former OfficeMax building into a modern multi-tenant retail asset.
The Property benefits from its position within Manitowoc’s primary retail corridor along Highway 42 / Calumet Avenue and is shadow anchored by a high-performing Walmart Supercenter. The surrounding trade area features a strong collection of national retailers, restaurants, and service providers that drive consistent consumer traffic and reinforce the corridor’s role as the market’s dominant shopping destination.
From an investment perspective, the Property offers a simple and durable operating profile supported by two complementary retail concepts, contractual rent growth, multiple renewal options, and a location within one of Manitowoc’s most established retail corridors. The combination of recent capital investment, national tenancy, and long-term lease structure provides investors with stable cash flow and embedded future income growth.
Documents:
| Title | ||
|---|---|---|
|
Offering Memorandum
|
Location
Gallery