5031 W Lake Rd
$985,000
5031 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757
24.6 acres
Lot Area
1908
Year Built
Details:
Highlights:
- Age: Over 50 Years Old
- Sewer: Public
- Water: Well
- Lot Size: 20-50 Acres
Description:
5031 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757 Positioned along the highly traveled Route 394 corridor between the renowned Chautauqua Institution and the Village of Mayville, Red Brick Farm presents a rare opportunity to acquire a landmark mixed-use property with significant redevelopment and investment potential. Situated on approximately 25 acres, the property consists of seven buildings offering a unique combination of hospitality, retail, residential, event, and commercial use possibilities.
Originally established as a turn-of-the-century dairy farm, the property has been thoughtfully transformed over the years into a destination featuring restaurant, retail, and residential components while preserving much of its historic character. The centerpiece of the property is the stately brick farmhouse, currently configured with restaurant space on the main level and residential living quarters above. Original architectural features, including hardwood floors, pocket doors, woodwork, and fireplaces, contribute to the property's distinctive appeal.
Additional improvements include a beautifully renovated barn with expansive open spaces suitable for events, hospitality, retail, or adaptive commercial uses, as well as a former milking barn and produce stand located adjacent to the primary parking area. Two additional retail buildings, constructed in 2003, provide further income-producing or redevelopment opportunities and are connected by a paved internal drive with access to additional parking and support facilities.
The property's largely level acreage offers ample room for outdoor programming, future expansion, and recreational uses. Natural features include a pond, wooded areas, and a private gas well that supplements utility service provided by National Fuel.
With strong visibility, substantial acreage, multiple structures, and a location at the gateway to Chautauqua Lake and Chautauqua Institution, Red Brick Farm represents a compelling value-add opportunity for investors, hospitality operators, event venue owners, developers, or entrepreneurs seeking a signature property in one of Western New York's most recognized tourism corridors.
Listing ID: e197bd41-307f-4199-930b-a6e0d9d9843f
Location
Gallery