Two Adjacent, Four-Story Mixed-Use Buildings in the Theatre District / Times Square
$9,000,000
321-323 West 51st Street, New York, NY 10019
For Sale
Mixed Use
Unknown Sub Type
Active
Last Updated: 01/20/2026
5.26
Cap Rate
473,063
NOI
Details:
Cap Rate: 5.26%
NOI: $473,063
Building Size: 10,016 sqft
Lot Area: 4,016 sqft
Zoning: R8 | CL
Highlights:
- First sale in over 50 years - opportunity to acquire two adjacent four-story buildings on West 51st Street in the core of the theater district
- Well-maintained asset with in-place income from a marquee restaurant tenant and 5 Free Market residential apartments above
- Exceptional Midtown West location surrounded by dense residential, office, hotel, and nightlife uses, supporting strong foot traffic and long-term demand
- Restaurant tenant’s lease expires on 7/31/26 allowing for renewal, re-tenanting or acquisition by an owner-operator
- Two adjacent tax lots totaling approximately 4,016 square feet of lot area and 10,016 square feet of existing building area
- Six total units across both buildings, including five residential units and one 4,000 sf ground-floor restaurant
- Zoned R8 with grandfathered commercial use, allowing for residential and mixed-use configurations consistent with surrounding development
- Approximate 6,851 square feet of unused air rights, providing long-term optionality for a future owner
Documents:
| Title | ||
|---|---|---|
| Listing Setup |
* Documents permissions are set by the listing owner, request information to access locked documents.
Location
Gallery