The Reserve at Petoskey
$750,000
501 W Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770
For Sale
Retail
Street Retail
Active
Last Updated: 07/14/2025
8.15
Cap Rate
61,099
NOI
Details:
Cap Rate: 8.15%
NOI: $61,099
Building Size: 6,406 sqft
Lot Area: 0.2582 acres
Occupancy: 100%
Units: 5
Year Built: 1970
Floors: 1
Highlights:
- The Heart of Petoskey, MI - Nearly 1 MILLION Visitors Annually from Across the United States and the World www.petoskeyarea.com
- Prime Visibility & Location – Frontage along W Mitchell St (US-31), Petoskey’s main commercial corridor with strong daily traffic counts
- Excellent Access & Parking – Easy ingress/egress with on-site parking; minutes from downtown, major retailers, and area amenities
- New Roof Unit 1 and 2 ($34,000) and Parking Lot Seal and Stripe 2024 Unit 3 and 4 Roof was Replaced in 2013 Concrete Replacement 2023 ($17,275)
- Upside in Rent Appreciation and Converting Leases from Gross to NNN
- Brand New Regional Lease – New 5-year lease with Cottage Inn Pizza, a trusted regional franchise with decades of brand recognition and a loyal customer base; long-term occupancy history supports stable, reliable income
- Cottage Inn Pizza Sets Goal is to Reach 100 Stores within 12 months!
- Comprehensive Build-out & Upgraded Systems – Cottage Inn will be doing an extensive interior build-out, but also an upgrade in all electrical and HVAC systems to the building to ensure modern functionality and reduce maintenance costs
- Existing Tenants Occupied the Property 14, 12 and 4 years, Respectively
- Flexible Commercial Use – Configured for retail, office, medical, or service users; adaptable layout supports a wide range of businesses
- Thriving Commercial Hub – Surrounded by national retailers, restaurants, medical offices, and local businesses generating steady foot traffic
- Affluent, Year-Round Market – Located in a stable, high-income resort community with strong seasonal tourism to boost business
- Healthcare-Adjacent Location – Directly across from McLaren Northern Michigan Hospital (400+ beds), ideal for medical or service-oriented tenants
Description:
.
er
52-19-06-126-021,
52-19-06-126-023
Location

Gallery

