request_info_guest false

Matecumbe Sandy Beach

$4,250,000

74560 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

Active
Last Updated: 11/22/2025

141,500

NOI

12,045 sqft

Building Size

Details:
NOI:    $141,500
Building Size:    12,045 sqft
Units:    2
Year Built:    1983
Floors:    3
Parking Spots:    15
Gross Leaseable Area:    6,071
Highlights:
  • Lot Features: Less Than 1/4 Acre Lot
  • Documents Available: Deposit - Security, Rent Rolls
  • Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s), Electric
  • Heating: None
  • Flooring: Ceramic Floor, Tile, Vinyl
  • Construction Materials: Concrete Block Construction, Concrete Block With Brick
Description:

?? NEW LISTING ANNOUNCEMENT
74560 Overseas Hwy – Islamorada, FL
Premium investment opportunity in the Florida Keys:
??? Listing Price (Firm): $4,250,000.00
?? Seller Financing Available
• 50% Down Payment
• 5.0% Interest – First Year Intro Rate
??? Property is 100% Leased
?? Additional Upside: First-Floor Commercial Lease Opportunity
?? Redevelopment Architectural Plans Completed
?? Water Rights Included – 45 ft Beyond the Rear Seawall
??? No Extra Insurance Cost — Liability Only
?? Major Updates completed.
?? Tours Only After Accepted Contract — Please Do Not Disturb Tenants.
A stabilized, turnkey asset in a prime Islamorada location with strong income, commercial upside, completed redevelopment plans, valuable water rights, and low insurance overhead with seller financing.
For financials, rent roll, or offer instructions, contact via email directly.
Walking distance to restaurants, shops, marinas, and more.

Map:
Location
Gallery